‘The Best Christmas Pageant Ever’ at Laurel Mill Playhouse

The Best Christmas Pageant Ever rings in the holidays at Laurel Mill Playhouse

In this busy season of shopping, baking and parties, it’s nice to take some time with our families to be gently reminded of what this holiday season is about. Laurel Mill Playhouse delivers a funny and heartwarming tale that not only entertains, but reminds us of the true meaning of Christmas. The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is just right for all ages. The action moves quickly and the length of this play is perfect for even the youngest family member.

Rachel Kilgallon and Raj Francis. Photo by John Cholod.
Rachel Kilgallon and Raj Francis. Photo by Valerie Kilgallon.

The story is about a couple who takes over the task of directing the church Christmas pageant when the original director takes ill. The struggles begin when they are forced to cast the most inventive and awful children who live in their town. Just their last name “Herdman” instills fear in every parent and child in town. The fun and hilarity begins as the show draws closer to its opening. The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is a comedy adapted from the best-selling young adult book by Barbara Robinson.

Director Rocky Nuzio creates some wonderful pictures on the stage and uses the space effectively moving his 16 actors from one tableau to the next with ease. There is one scene in particular where he has several conversations going on at once from stage right, center and left that was exceedingly well done creating the chaos and humor needed for that moment in the play. I found it to be inventive and a good use of the space.

The set design was a collaboration between Producer Maureen Rogers, Stage Manager Deborah Gur, and Director Rocky Nuzio. The design was simple, but highly effective giving the impression that the stage was a large handmade Christmas card painted with classic red and green, covered in paper snowflakes and personalized Christmas stockings for each cast member. Two platforms adorned both sides of the stage with an archway in the center which doubles as a manger for the Christmas pageant. The center backdrop of the stage is painted with the town of Bethlehem.

The set design was highlighted by Michael Hartsfield’s excellent use of light to bring out the colors of the simple, but lovely Christmas card created in the stage design.

Kudos go to Music Director William Georg for his impeccable use of the well-blended voices of the children singing along with recorded Christmas carols.  Christmas carols were used throughout the play as interludes that segue from one scene to another. Even at the end of the play within a play, there is a cast and audience sing along to “Joy to the World.”

Costume Designer Carol Mead Cartmell did a wonderful job especially with the actual Christmas pageant costumes. In particular, the angels adorned with wings and halos and the beauty and simplicity of Mary’s classic costume. Her costumes in the pageant gave the play-within-a-play its authenticity.

Maureen Rogers (Mother) and David McCrary (Father) gave excellent performances as the couple saddled with the task of directing the pageant.  Maureen Rogers’ warmth in the midst of chaos was real and heartfelt, and David McCrary’s great comic timing gave a sense of realism to the piece.

Patrick Pase (Reverend Hopkins) also deserves kudos for his delivery of one of the funniest lines in the play when talking about the out of control Herdman children, “When God said, suffer the little children that come unto me, I don’t think he was talking about the Herdmans.” I should also mention that the part of Reverend Hopkins was double-cast. Ron Able is also Reverend Hopkins in other performances during the run of the show.

L to R: Carly Pometto and Maureen Rogers. Photo by Valerie Kilgallon.
L to R: Carly Pometto and Maureen Rogers. Photo by Valerie Kilgallon.

The Herdmans were played by six talented children and teens Olivia Brady (Olivia Herdman), Raj Francis (Ralph Herdman), Dani Kellner (Lily Herdman), Rachel Kilgallon (Imogene Herdman), Victoria Simmons (Claudette Herdman), and little Carly Pometto (Gladys Herdman). The quips and well-timed humor that the children blurted out during the telling of the story of the first Christmas was priceless.

Two standout performances go to Carly Pometto (Gladys Herdman) and Tiana Bell (Charley Bradley) who were also the youngest members of the cast. They both gave high energy performances with amazing comic timing. Carly’s Gladys was constantly in motion flying across the stage as if she was a super hero, and Tiana’s Charley was funny with a hint of sarcasm in her line delivery. Both young ladies delivered exceedingly memorable performances.

Diana Reed (Beth Bradley) played the older sister of Charley, as well as the storyteller of the play. Diana does a lovely job breaking down the fourth wall and talking directly to the audience as she tells them the tale of the Herdman Christmas pageant.

The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is definitely an ensemble piece of theater.  Everyone in the show delivered a wonderful performance. Included in the ensemble of actors were Alexandra Fortune (Denise), Sienna Johnson (Holly), Spencer Kate (Mrs. Armstrong), Dave Martinek (Elmer), and Katelyn Shibilski (Alice Wendleken).

If you are looking for a fun evening of theater for the whole family and a dose of some good old Christmas spirit, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever at Laurel Mill Playhouse delivers it and then some.

Running Time: Approximately 45 minutes, with no intermission.


The Best Christmas Pageant Ever plays through December 20th 2015 at Laurel Mill Playhouse – 508 Main Street, in Laurel, MD. For tickets, call the box office at (301) 617-9906, or purchase them online.

RATING: FIVE-STARS-82x1546.gif

Previous articleScene Stealers/Showstoppers of the Week-Part 2: December 2, 2015
Next article‘The Bald Soprano’ at Curio Theatre Company in Philadelphia
Ilene Chalmers
Ilene has been an avid theater goer, performer and director for more than 40 years. Theater is Ilene’s first love and always has been from a very young age. She graduated with a B.A. degree in theater from the University of Maryland. In the early 1980s, she was a restaurant and theater reviewer for The Gaithersburg Gazette. Starting in the 1990s into the 2000s, Ilene was an English and Drama teacher in both Montgomery County Public Schools and The Harbour School in Annapolis. Ilene resides in Elkridge with fellow actor and husband David and their Cavalier King Charles Spaniel Molly. Her proudest productions of late are her four wonderful grandchildren. She is extremely proud to be a member of DCMetroTheaterArts staff of writers.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here