Review: ‘The Manor’ by Colonial Playhouse

For fifteen years, a California theater company has been presenting the drama The Manor in the Greystone Mansion in Beverly Hills — an appropriate spot because the play is based on a true murder and suicide of rich and famous men in that home.

Marcia Hepps and Annaliese Gove. Photo by Paul Mackey.
Marcia Hepps and Annaliese Gove. Photo by Paul Mackey.

Now the Colonial Playhouse, a community theater company in Aldan, Delaware County, is presenting The Manor at Greystone Hall in West Chester, Chester County, in what was once a thousand-acre country estate. Audience members are led from room to room in the mansion as the narrative unfolds.

This story is based on the real life of Edward Doheny, an oil tycoon in the 1920s. President Harding’s Secretary of the Interior Albert Fall received a bribe from Doheny and leased U.S. government petroleum reserves at Teapot Dome in Wyoming to Doheny’s company at a low rate without competitive bidding. Fall went to jail for this; he was the first Cabinet official to go to prison.

Secretary Fall also was suspected of the 1896 murder of rival politician Albert Fountain and his eight-year-old son in New Mexico. This public official apparently was, to use Donald Trump’s words, virtually a man who “could shoot a man on Fifth Avenue and get away with it.” Upton Sinclair’s 1927 novel Oil! (the inspiration for the 2007 film There Will Be Blood starring Daniel Day-Lewis) includes a character based on Doheny. The famed crime novelist Raymond Chandler included this murder-suicide in his The High Window. To avoid legal exposure, playwright Kathrine Bates renamed the family “MacAlister” and she calls this “a fictionalized story inspired by true events.” This is its East Coast premiere.

The estate is an important part of the drama, because it reveals the aura of privilege that led the characters to act above the law, with a sense of entitlement. This property was designed by architect Charles Keen, whose best known project other than Greystone is the Winston-Salem, North Carolina estate built for the R.J. Reynolds tobacco family. We reach the mansion after a mile-long drive through deep woods along a twisted gravel road. All of the rooms are elegantly furnished, so it seems thoroughly appropriate when we find ourselves attending the wedding reception for the tycoon’s son and his bride, where gifts are delivered from Charlie Chaplin and William Randolph Hearst.

Tom Karolyi and Lauren Jones. Photo by Michael Brun.
Tom Karolyi and Lauren Jones. Photo by Michael Brun.

The U. S. Senator (changed from the actual Secretary of the Interior) who solicits the bribe is well-played with brash ego by David Cashell. The wealthy owner of the estate is depicted gregariously by Stephen Kelly. He emerges here as a man reluctantly induced into a criminal enterprise. The wives of those men are touchingly portrayed by Annaliese Gove and Marcia Hepps. A wonderful scene in the piano room reveals how they deal with their domineering husbands.

The MacAlister son Sean is attractively played by the clean-cut Ryan Cassidy. Tom Karolyi convincingly interprets Sean’s friend Greg who accompanies the delivery of the bribe to Washington. That actor does a great job depicting his anguish as he’s questioned by prosecutors, and his gradual descent into depression and alcoholism. Kaitlin Healy sympathetically limns Sean’s innocent wife. Lawrence Geller is outstanding as the avuncular family lawyer.

Those of us who study history knew that a killing would occur but, still, we’re in suspense about how it will happen. There’s a buildup of tension, and mystery about the motive. In our era when rich deal-makers are in power, this drama is chillingly relevant. It’s gripping to watch how these wheeler-dealers handle themselves as investigators close in on them.

I saw a somewhat-similar conception by the Philadelphia Artists’ Collective at the 2015 Fringe Festival, The Captive, performed in close proximity to the audience in two rooms of the Physick House in downtown Philly. This production of The Manor lavishly expands upon that, a thousand-fold.

As directed by Sam Barrett, the action flows naturally from Great Hall to library to conservatory to bride’s dressing room. There are enough chairs and couches for audience members to sit while we follow the drama. Annaliese and Gaby Gove chose the elegant period costumes.

I hope we’ll be able to see repeats of this unique, outstanding production in the future.

Running Time: Two hours and 15 minutes, with one intermission.

The Ensemble. Photo by Michael Brun.
The Ensemble. Photo by Michael Brun.

The Manor plays through Sunday, November 12, 2017 and is presented by Colonial Playhouse, performing at Greystone Hall – 1034 Phoenixville Pike, in West Chester, PA. Tickets may be purchased online.


  1. I was at the same performance and I found it to be excellent and extremely enjoyable. I felt like I was almost by myself evs-dropping in on the conversations. The movement about help make time fly and it seemed as if it were only a short time. The break (intermission) was also great. The nice little finger foods added to the great charm of this beautiful setting. A unique idea for this type of play would be for a short period have the small audience discus among themselves who is going to be bumped off. While I was watching it I kept thinking about who would be shot. I could make a case for almost anyone. I thought the two older wives conversation in the piano room was precious and showed the real skill of these actresses. Anyone who has the privilege to see this performance, if it is done again, should certainly do so. Thanks so much to the Colonial Playhouse and especially to the owner of Greystone Manor.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here