Funny, fast-paced, and warm ‘White Christmas’ at Toby’s Dinner Theatre 

The production puts new spins on old standards, livening up comfortable treats with the spice of novelty.

The holidays are the time for the tried and true. Thanksgiving doesn’t seem like Thanksgiving without our favorite dishes from childhood bringing back warm memories, and Yuletide wouldn’t be the same without the movies we grew up with. At the same time, artists put new spins on old standards for new generations, livening up comfortable old treats with the spice of novelty.

White Christmas, currently playing at Toby’s Dinner Theatre, illustrates this perfectly. Based on the beloved 1954 film with Bing Crosby, it has become a holiday theater staple, touring worldwide since its introduction in 2000 with stints on Broadway in 2008 and 2009. Including most of the songs from the film — including the title song, which in 1940 established that there was a popular market for secular Christmas music and became the best-selling pop single of all time — the stage version adds several more, all by Irving Berlin. 

David James, Rachel Cahoon, Janine Sunday, Jeffrey Shankle starring in ‘White Christmas.’ Photo by Jeri Tidwell Photography.

Toby’s production hits just the right balance between tradition and change. Director Mark Minnick keeps everything funny, fast-paced, and above all warm, while adding some novelty with expert use of the theater’s in-the-round staging. One of the best examples is the Act One closer, “Blue Skies,” a full-on production number crisscrossed by several characters chasing each other. 

The entire production is saved from being too sweet by Ross Scott Rawlings and his excellent orchestra wah-wahhing their way through the delicious harmonies of Berlin’s songs. The singers make the most of these, too, particularly in the lovely quartet “Snow,” and the Andrews Sisters–style “Falling Out Of Love Can Be Fun.” All the songs feel like old friends, including “Sisters,” “Count Your Blessings Instead of Sheep,” and “Let Yourself Go.” Similarly, Christen Svingos’s choreography keeps things lively, including multiple tap numbers. One of them, the Act Two opener, “I Love a Piano,” has characters tapping both while sitting down and on top of a very baby grand. 

Shane Lowry’s serviceable set pieces, because they all involve the literal heavy lifting of being moved entirely on and off between scenes, cannot do much heavy lifting visually. But Sarah King and Janine Sunday’s costumes make up the gap and then some. They are reminiscent of the movie, as in the classic red gowns with white fur in the finale, but improve on it, such as lower necklines on the classic blue dresses in “Sisters” or the spectacular black gown in the torch song “Love, You Didn’t Do Right By Me,” which keeps the stunning diamond brooch in the small of the back but adds a smashing asymmetrical neckline and red ruffled lining. Sunday has her work cut out for her, not only co-creating the costumes, but wearing this gown as leading lady Betty Haines, which she does beautifully, turning Rosemary Clooney’s quiet crooning into a belting showstopper.

‘I Love a Piano’ (Rachel Cahoon, David James and company) in ‘White Christmas.’ Photo by Jeri Tidwell Photography.

All of this lovely feeling of tradition is enhanced by the cast, many of whom will be familiar to faithful patrons. Jeffrey Shankle (Helen Hayes Award winner for Bottom in Something Rotten) delivers the Bing Crosby part, if not with quite the velvet voice of the original, then with Broadway panache, humor, and a lovely sincerity when gazing at Betty. David James (HH winner for Scarecrow in Wizard of Oz) makes a charming, spirited Phil, tapping up a storm with Rachel Cahoon (HH-nominated for Maria in Sound of Music) as the spitfire Judy Haines. Robert Biedermann, long the pre-show emcee at Toby’s, also has a chance to tug some heartstrings here as General Waverly. And one of the best additions to the musical is the expansion of the character of Martha the housekeeper, who becomes a Mermanesque ex-Broadway belter, here embodied for the fourth time by powerhouse Jane C. Boyle in her 35th Toby’s production. And props to Shawn Ketterling (HH-nominated for Uncle Fester in The Addams Family), who, across his four roles in the show, nails Ezekiel Foster, the laconic Vermont handyman with the secret heart of a hoofer. So for Toby’s regulars, White Christmas is a homecoming of its own. 

The ambiance around the show continues the feeling of a warm hug, from the comfort food of the dinner buffet to many patrons dressed in holiday finery. Toby’s will close after its next show (Grease, opening on January 15) to complete the overhaul of the theater after 47 years, and will reopen in April in a brand-new, expanded facility, so we shall see what changes that will bring, and what traditions will remain. 

But at a recent evening at White Christmas, a patron was heard to say enthusiastically, “It was exactly what I expected!” For a holiday show at Toby’s, that’s the highest praise.

Running Time: Two hours and 30 minutes with one intermission.

Irving Berlin’s White Christmas plays through January 10, 2027, at Toby’s Dinner Theatre, 5900 Symphony Woods Road, Columbia, MD. Tickets, including dinner and show (adult, $78–$94; child, $67–$70), can be purchased by calling 410-730-8311 or online.

The menu is here. The playbill is here.

Note that Toby’s Dinner Theater is open while under construction. To drop off patrons, enter Toby’s entrance located on Symphony Woods Road. Parking is available next door at the Symphony Woods Office Center, 5950 Symphony Woods Rd. Shuttles run continuously before and after the show, but the parking is also an easy walk.

Previous articleIn ‘Takes All Kinds,’ Dan Hoyle shares a secret for saving democracy
Jennifer Georgia
Over the past [mumble] decades, Jennifer has acted, directed, costumed, designed sets, posters, and programs, and generally theatrically meddled on several continents. She has made a specialty of playing old bats — no, make that “mature, empowered women” — including Lady Bracknell in Importance of Being Earnest (twice); Mama Rose in Gypsy and the Wicked Stepmother in Cinderella at Montgomery Playhouse; Dolly in Hello, Dolly! and Carlotta in Follies in Switzerland; and Golde in Fiddler on the Roof and Mrs. Higgins in My Fair Lady in London. (Being the only American in a cast of 40, playing the woman who taught Henry Higgins to speak, was nerve-racking until a fellow actor said, “You know, it’s quite odd — when you’re on stage you haven’t an accent at all.”) She has no idea why she keeps getting cast as these imposing matriarchs; she is quite easygoing. Really. But Jennifer also indulges her lust for power by directing shows including You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown and Follies. Most recently, she directed, costumed, and designed and painted the set for Rockville Little Theatre’s She Stoops to Conquer, for which she won the WATCH Award for Outstanding Set Painting. In real life, she is a speechwriter and editor, and tutors learning-challenged kids for standardized tests and application essays.