Neil Simon’s classic ‘The Odd Couple’ is very enjoyable at Castaways Theatre

Danny Seal as Felix and Jason Foster as Oscar carry the show with solid performances and great comedic chemistry.

Castaways Theatre recently opened Neil Simon’s comedy The Odd Couple in Woodbridge, Virginia. Fabulous timing, considering the play is slated to return to Broadway in March 2027 for a 15-week limited engagement starring Steve Carell and John C. Reilly. The play premiered on Broadway in 1965, then became a major motion picture in 1968 with Walter Matthau and Jack Lemmon, which was so successful that it was developed into a sitcom in 1970. Since then, the work has appeared in mainstream media in the form of adaptations, remounts, and sequels at a steady pace.

What makes this 60-plus-year-old story so appealing is the relatability of its main characters’ plight and their hilarious, human flaws. The plot follows two recently divorced men who become roommates. Despite the fact that the men are long-time friends, their mismatched personalities and stark habitation differences create ample fodder for intense disagreements, outbursts, and melodrama.

Danny Seal and Jason Foster in ‘The Odd Couple.’ Photo by Bob Thompson.

While the dialogue contains some groaner comments about women and female stereotypes, the script is equally critical of men and highlights the simple fact that we are all imperfect and no relationship can survive without compromise. 

At the center of the action is the neurotic and obsessively tidy Felix Unger, played by Danny Seal. And Jason Foster is the slovenly gambler, Oscar Madison. Kudos to the casting because Seal and Foster are a match made in heaven. Or rather, for the purposes of this review, a match made in hell. Felix and Oscar can easily be made into caricatures only meant for laughs, but each actor gives them depth and a realness that is endearing, even when their actions are outlandishly childish or ridiculous. 

Seal is endearing and portrays Felix’s misguided, depressed theatrics with sincerity, showing a deeply insecure man with a heart of gold who, with a little confidence and some Prozac, can move forward with his life to better things.

Foster, too, is charming and gives Oscar a softness under his gruff and angry exterior. Lacking direction and motivation to take care of himself, let alone anyone else, makes him familiar. If we haven’t been there ourselves, we likely all know someone like him who is too deep in their own misery to see their way out. Foster brings that humanity to an otherwise stock character that would be easy to dismiss or despise.

Playing the flirty neighbors invited for a double date were Tammy Barboza and Alexis “Lexy” Janda Knott, as Gwendolyn Pigeon and Cecily Pigeon, respectively. Barboza and Knott were charming and silly. Their characters don’t get a lot of stage time, but the duo make the most of it and nail the sister energy.

Steve Rosenthal stood out as Murray, an NYPD policeman and one of Felix and Oscar’s poker buddies. Rosenthal’s Murray brought a genuine kindness and concern for his friends that was lovely to watch only to then be amusingly contrasted by his grumpy griping about his wife, which seemed more for show than any real animosity. Rounding out the poker team was Speed (Tobias Schroeder), Roy (Meighan Hogate), and Vinnie (Syed Pervez). 

The script is in three short acts, which all take place in Oscar’s apartment. Set designer and director Eddie Page has created a realistic living room, with a dining and seating area as the main stage, a door to the kitchen and bathroom, and a hallway in between. The layout works well and allows for constant traffic through the home, avoiding moments with too much stillness, which can be an unfortunate result of a static setting.

On a technical note, the scene changes were slow and broke the otherwise quick and energetic pacing. This could be remedied with a little more coordination and simplification. One change in particular required a table being set for a meal with various plates, napkins, glasses, and a centerpiece, and it felt painfully long.

Playing music during these transitions would work wonders in filling the air and making the time go by in a more purposeful way. Sound tech Michelle Matthews delighted the audience by opening the event with the original “Odd Couple theme song,” composed by jazz trumpeter, composer, and arranger Neal Hefti. Replaying that clip during those breaks between scenes could be a treat for the audience.

Overall, Castaways Theatre’s mounting of The Odd Couple was very enjoyable. Seal and Foster carry the show with solid performances and great comedic chemistry. Congratulations to the cast and crew for a fun and lively production.

Running Time: Approximately two hours and 30 minutes, with one 15-minute intermission.

The Odd Couple plays through November 22, 2026, presented by Castaways Theatre, performing at the AJ Ferlazzo Building located at 15941 Donald Curtis Drive, Woodbridge, VA. Tickets cost $20 for adults ($21.75 w/ fees) and $10 for kids 12 and under ($11.25 w/ fees) for General Seating and can be purchased online or at the door. Discount tickets ($19.65 w/ fees) are available for seniors, students, active military personnel and veterans, first responders and Prince William County employees and can be purchased at the door with proper ID.

The Odd Couple

CAST
Speed: Tobias Schroeder; Murray: Steve Rosenthal; Roy: Meighan Hogate; Vinnie: Syed Pervez; Oscar Madison: Jason Foster; Felix Unger: Danny Seal; Gwendolyn Pigeon: Tammy Barboza; Cecily Pigeon: Alexis “Lexy” Janda Knott

PRODUCTION CREW
Director/Co Set Dressing and Props/Set Designer: Eddie Page; Producer/Marketing/Co Set Dressing and Props: Bob Thompson; Stage Manager: Mary Beth Smith-Toomey; Costume Design: Michelle Harris; Set Builder/Tech Director: Dale Carleson; Sound Design: Silas Andrews; Lights and Sound Tech/Board Operator: Michelle Matthews; Program Design/Layout: Elena Thompson