Charming new play ‘Fiveplay’ depicts housemates with benefits

From the Coil Project comes an inviting show of possibility for polyamorous playmaking.

The preshow soundtrack bears a distant resemblance to the theme from Friends. And like that hugely successful TV sitcom, Erica Smith’s charming new play Fiveplay is set in the shared household of an assortment of idiosyncratic personalities in their twenties. But there the similarity ends, because the housemates of Fiveplay are all polyamorous, which one of them helpfully explains early on, in an amusing teach-the-audience scene:

AVERY: Polyamory is being involved in multiple committed relationships at once with — and this is the most important part — the full consent of everyone involved. Also referred to as a form of ethical nonmonogamy. I’m gonna repeat that: ETHICAL nonmonogamy.

Someday some smart TV producer is going to notice the zeitgeist is ready for a sitcom based on this provocative premise — it’s only a matter of time, what with the heteronormative gender binary on the wane. Perhaps that polyamorous reimagining of Friends will be inspired by Fiveplay, who knows? In the meantime, there are two more chances next weekend to check out this inviting show of possibility for character-driven polyamorous playmaking.

The tricky thing is — as I discovered at the very beginning of the Coil Project production amiably directed by Sean Butler — that when the cast of characters is polyamorous, keeping track of who’s having relations with whom can get complicated. So you’ll thank me, when you see Fiveplay, for this handy color-coded diagram.

Christine Smith (Avery), Rocky Nunzio (Keegan), Michael Silver (Monty), Brianna Goode (Ray), Eric Jones (Sawyer), and Rebecca Rose Vassy (Emerson) in ‘Fiveplay.’ Photo by Eric Cline.

One of the most interesting things about Fiveplay is what it’s not. There’s a lot of situationally appropriate hugging, kissing, and other casual affection and a lot of banter about an upcoming special event (a house orgy they call Fucksgiving), but no clothes come off, there are no sex acts, and nobody objectifies or body-judges anyone else. The actors who very capably play the five polyamorous characters — Brianna Goode (as Ray), Eric Jones (as Sawyer), Michael Silver (as Monty), Christine Smith (as Avery), and Rebecca Rose Vassy (a strong-willed stand out as Emerson)and the sole character not coupled — Rocky Nunzio (as Keegan) — live in the moment in their interrelationships as if nothing at all out of the ordinary is going on. It’s simply their chosen everyday family, they are refreshingly at ease in it, and the eroticism between them can be sweetly funny, as in this exploratory exchange (not yet diagramed above):

RAY: You’re a good person.
SAWYER: Oh. Thank you.
RAY: You… are… also… a… very… foxy person.
SAWYER: I, uh, I guess I’m okay—
RAY: I have a thing for you.
SAWYER: Okay. What is it?
RAY: What is what?
SAWYER: The thing you have for me.
RAY: Oh geez. Uh.
A crush. For. On you. I have. Yes. I have a crush on you.
A lot of your recent comments suddenly make a lot more sense.

When during the course of the play dramatic conflicts arise, it’s never about jealousy or betrayal or any stereotype one might have about these people’s multiple sex-partnering. Instead, it’s tensions and incursions from outside — such as an antique suspected of being haunted, the curtly texted news of a beloved grandfather’s death, the antipathy of offstage parents — all episodes that while not particularly earthmoving nevertheless illustrate how the premise of polyamorous housemates could well be deployed in a pilot.

Rebecca Rose Vassy (Emerson) Eric Jones (Sawyer) in ‘Fiveplay.’ Photo by Eric Cline.

The sound design by Sean Butler effectively suggests a rainstorm during a sequence when a ghost may or may not be present, at which time the lighting design by Jason Aufdem-Brinke also backlights everyone in an ominous blue. The uncredited set looks credibly lived in — a worn sofa, mismatched tables and chairs, pride flags and queer bric-a-brac all about. The uncredited costumes have the fascinating specificity one would expect of an intuitive designer’s hand but instead likely came from the director and actors’ apt insights into the characters.

High budget and polished this production is not. But the forward-looking creative concept, the intriguing character delineations, and the vision of ethical eroticism make Fiveplay well worth a trip to the black box at Capitol Hill Arts Workshop.

Running Time: 80 minutes, with no intermission.

Fiveplay runs April 8–9, 15–16, and 22–23, 2022, presented by the Coil Project performing in the black box theater of the Capitol Hill Arts Workshop at 545 7th Street SE, Washington, DC. All shows start at 8 pm. Tickets ($20) can be purchased online.

COVID Safety: The Capital Hill Workshop requires that audience members remain masked (N95 or KN95) in public spaces of the building. CHAW’s complete COVID-19 Safety Protocols are here.

Written by Erica Smith
Directed by Sean Butler
Produced by Rebecca Fischler

Brianna Goode as Ray
Eric Jones as Sawyer
Rocky Nunzio as Keegan
Michael Silver as Monty
Christine Smith as Avery
Rebecca Rose Vassy as Emerson

Sound design by Sean Butler
Lighting design by Jason Aufdem-Brinke

The Coil Project to open ‘Fiveplay’ about modern polyamory (news story)

Previous articlePan Asian Rep’s Off-Broadway world premiere of ‘Citizen Wong’ looks at Asian and American relations in the Gilded Age
Next articleCelebrating Black femme vision in ‘Dreamgirls’ at Bowie State University
John Stoltenberg
John Stoltenberg is executive editor of DC Theater Arts. He writes both reviews and his Magic Time! column, which he named after that magical moment between life and art just before a show begins. In it, he explores how art makes sense of life—and vice versa—as he reflects on meanings that matter in the theater he sees. Decades ago, in college, John began writing, producing, directing, and acting in plays. He continued through grad school—earning an M.F.A. in theater arts from Columbia University School of the Arts—then lucked into a job as writer-in-residence and administrative director with the influential experimental theater company The Open Theatre, whose legendary artistic director was Joseph Chaikin. Meanwhile, his own plays were produced off-off-Broadway, and he won a New York State Arts Council grant to write plays. Then John’s life changed course: He turned to writing nonfiction essays, articles, and books and had a distinguished career as a magazine editor. But he kept going to the theater, the art form that for him has always been the most transcendent and transporting and best illuminates the acts and ethics that connect us. He tweets at @JohnStoltenberg. Member, American Theatre Critics Association.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here