Triune Entertainment’s Finding Neverland takes audiences on a nostalgic adventure of childlike wonder and imagination. The production features music and lyrics by Gary Barlow and Eliot Kennedy and a book by James Graham, and follows playwright J.M. Barrie as he tries to write his next successful story. His chance encounter with Sylvia Llewelyn Davies and her four young sons changes the trajectory of his life and leads to the creation of one of the most famous stories in history.
The star of the show is the leading man, Brian Donohue as J.M. Barrie. Donohue portrays the character with sincerity and wonder as he undergoes a major shift in his life and career. I especially enjoyed his vocal performance, demonstrating great versatility and stamina in the demanding role. His counterpart, Sylvia, is played by Jennifer Ayers with another strong vocal performance. The two performers are well matched and have the audience in the palm of their hands.
Director Renée De Ponte uses the Journey Theater to its full potential, creating entertaining moments of spectacle as well as quiet captivating authenticity. Choreography from Abby Rozmajzl and Abby Chaumont is joyous and energetic, particularly during the large-scale numbers that involve the entire company. Lighting design by Jack Tessier is effective in helping distinguish between the reality of 1900s England and the heightened imagination of Barrie.
The rambunctious Llewelyn Davies children are well cast and full of energy, often seen play-fighting in the background as an added dose of authenticity. Brendan Balint as Peter is a particular standout with great maturity in his acting. I also enjoyed the performances of Mrs. du Marier (Monica Kelly), Charles Frohman (Brad Broemmel), and Mary Barrie (Melissa Rihl) and their contrasting perspectives to J.M. Barrie and Sylvia Llewelyn Davies. Their musical number “Circus of Your Mind” was my favorite of the evening.
Like any live theatrical evening, the production was not without its hiccups. On opening night, there were some technical issues related to sound that resulted in a few lines and lyrics becoming difficult to hear. The issues were quickly resolved and the performers maintained their characters so the storytelling could continue. Performing to pre-recorded tracks can be a tricky feat, and the cast does an admirable job with their entrances and harmonies under the guidance of music director Cate Murray.
Triune Entertainment’s Finding Neverland is a solid production that is both entertaining and inspiring for the entire family.
Running Time: Two hours and 25 minutes, with a 15-minute intermission.
Finding Neverland plays through November 1, 2026, presented by Triune Entertainment LLC, performing at Journey Theatre, 4175 Bludau Dr, Warrenton, VA. Purchase tickets ($27 for adults, $23 for children) online or at the door.
Finding Neverland
Director: Rénee De Ponte
Producer: Matt Moore
Stage Manager: Mary Beth Balint
Music Director: Cate Murray
Choreographers: Abby Chaumont and Abby Rozmajzl
Assistant Director: Ryan Balint
Technical Directors: Ben Jacobeen and Jack Tessier
SEE ALSO:
Triune’s ‘Finding Neverland’ is big on heart and imagination (review by Natasha Parmian, October 28, 2026)
