Sterling Playmakers’ ‘Camelot’ is uneven but has bright spots

Despite its mixed results, the production is worth seeing.

How to handle a warhorse? The final collaboration between Alan Jay Lerner and Frederick Loewe, Camelot — after a famously disastrous out-of-town tryout saga — succeeded in its 1960 Broadway production through the talents of its stars, Richard Burton, Julie Andrews, and Robert Goulet, and a lavish physical production. The score has always featured beautiful songs. The book, especially after the cuts made to get the show’s running time within bounds, has always been something of a mess.

So how does a community theater grapple with the demands and limitations of the material? In the case of Sterling Playmakers’ current production, the results are decidedly mixed. There are bright spots. The villain, Mordred (Leecy Silk), a sort of medieval Roy Cohn figure, is wonderfully sly, skillfully finding and exploiting the weaknesses of other characters to bring chaos out of the order painstakingly constructed by King Arthur (Alden Michels). Silk captures Mordred’s delight in tearing down the moral foundation of the Round Table in “The Seven Deadly Virtues.” Silk also gets the production’s best costume, a well-constructed and decorated black outfit that fits the actor and character perfectly.

Mordred (Leecy Silk), Arthur’s illegitimate son, plots with Morgan Le Fey (Marguerite Driessen), Mordred’s Aunt, to take down King Arthur in ‘Camelot.’ Photo by Courtney Garofolo.

Michels, who displays a pleasing voice in the title song and “How to Handle a Woman,” has his best moment in the stirring monologue that concludes the first act. He and Cameo Manning, as Guenevere, have good musical and character interaction in moments like “What Do the Simple Folk Do?” As Lancelot, Sean Love effectively sings his big numbers, “C’est Moi” and “If Ever I Would Leave You.” With the best female voice in the show, Rebecca Roberts as Nimue shines in the brief “Follow Me.” In a substantial supporting role as the daft but kindly King Pellinore, Chris Dockins is a lively comic presence throughout.

Some aspects of the production are problematic, however. A key part of Camelot’s plot is that Lancelot and Guenevere fall madly, deeply, hopelessly in love, risking everything dear to them. Their songs and lines say so. But for whatever reason — the dialogue writing (particularly Lancelot’s lines), direction, or scene partner chemistry issues — the passion didn’t land in this production. 

The production uses a pre-recorded score. Aside from unnecessarily prolonging the evening by playing the overture and entr’acte, the music sometimes creates awkward intervals in the action that the production struggles to fill with uninteresting ensemble movement. I can imagine a Broadway production using these interludes to display big-budget pageantry, but here they slow the show’s pace at times. Pre-recorded scores also constrain the interpretive choices of singers.

TOP: Cameo Manning (Guenevere) and the cast perform ‘The Lusty Month of May’; ABOVE: Cameo Manning (Guenevere) and Alden Michels (Arthur) sing the title song ‘Camelot’ in ‘Camelot.’ Photos by Chip Gertzog.

The ensemble is large, and its movement sometimes seems less like choreography than traffic management. Director Megan Fraedrich sometimes handles the issue by sending part of the group up the aisles. Ensemble members are frequently blocked in lines, for example during “The Jousts,” when they sing their description of offstage mounted combat. A similar approach worked beautifully for Lerner and Loewe in My Fair Lady’s Ascot scene. It is less effective in Camelot. The men in the ensemble provided a rousing ode to violence and sexual misconduct in the second act’s “Fie on Goodness,” while the staging of the dramatic “Guenevere” did not cohere.

Much of Allison Ball’s ensemble costuming resembled attractively colorful Renaissance Faire garb, with Lancelot and other knights distinguished by their red vests. Merlyn (K Sridhar) was dressed as a magician, wearing a purple robe with a pointed, star-studded hat. The costume for Morgan Le Fey (Marguerite Driessen) was elegantly witchy; her female attendants lined up in brown and orange dresses. The leads’ outfits, flattering neither Guenevere nor Arthur, were not suggestive of royalty. 

Perhaps because of resource limitations affecting what is a very large show, the sets and lighting design were rudimentary. I have seen Sterling Playmakers do better (e.g., in the 2022 Ragtime).

While never the best of the so-called “Golden Age” musicals, Camelot is an infrequently produced example of a style of musical that is an important part of the Broadway theater tradition (though it was the subject of a 2023 New York revival, with the book rewritten by Aaron Sorkin). Notwithstanding an uneven production, it is worth the opportunity to see.

Running Time: Two hours and 40 minutes, including one intermission.

Lerner and Loewe’s Camelot plays through November 22, 2026, presented by Sterling Playmakers, performing at Seneca Ridge Middle School, 98 Seneca Ridge Dr, Sterling, VA. Tickets are $20 and available online or in person at the box office.

Lerner and Loewe’s Camelot
Book and Lyrics by Alan Jay Lerner
Music by Frederick Loewe
Original Production Directed and Staged by Moss Hart
Based on “The Once and Future King” by T.H. White
Produced by Kimberly Fry
Directed by Megan Fraedrich
Music Directed by Lauren Baker

The cast credits are here.